Apple’s recent decision to reject the submissions of iDOS 3 and UTM SE, two popular retro video game emulators, has caused quite a stir in the developer community. The rejection was based on guideline 4.7 of the App Review Guidelines, which allows for retro game emulators on the App Store. However, Apple found both iDOS 3 and UTM SE to be in violation of this guideline, citing specific reasons for the rejection.
Chaoji Li, the developer of iDOS 3, shared Apple’s reasoning for the rejection with The Verge. According to Apple, the app did not specifically emulate a retro game console, which is a requirement for compliance with guideline 4.7. Similarly, UTM SE was rejected because Apple deemed that “PC is not a console,” despite the fact that the app could run retro Windows and DOS games.
Both developers expressed frustration with Apple’s vague reasoning and lack of guidance on how to make their apps compliant. Chaoji Li mentioned in a blog post that Apple’s response was along the lines of “we know it when we see it,” leaving developers in the dark about what changes need to be made. UTM also noted that Apple’s decision-making process can be inconsistent and unpredictable, putting developers at a disadvantage.
Apple’s clarification on guideline 4.7 added to the confusion, as it stated that the exception for offering certain software not embedded in the binary only applies to App Store apps, which UTM SE did not qualify for. This left developers wondering what criteria Apple uses to determine compliance with its guidelines, and how they can ensure their apps meet the requirements.
The rejection of iDOS 3 and UTM SE highlights the challenges developers face when trying to navigate Apple’s App Store guidelines. As the sole rule maker and enforcer in the iOS ecosystem, Apple’s decisions can have a significant impact on developers’ ability to offer innovative apps and services to users. This situation underscores the need for more transparency and consistency in Apple’s app review process.
The rejection of iDOS 3 and UTM SE by Apple raises important questions about the company’s approach to app store review and its impact on developers. As Apple continues to face antitrust scrutiny and regulatory pressure, it is essential for developers to stay informed about the guidelines and requirements for submitting apps to the App Store. By understanding Apple’s expectations and working to meet them, developers can increase their chances of getting their apps approved and reaching a wider audience.
Leave a Reply